Every martial art is a tool, and tools are good at different jobs. The honest answer to "which is best?" is "best at what?" Below is how the popular options stack up — including where Krav Maga isn't the obvious pick.
| Style | Best for | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Krav Maga | Practical self-defence, fast to learn, weapons & multiple attackers | Not a competitive sport; quality varies by school |
| Boxing | Hands, footwork, head movement, conditioning | No grappling, kicks or weapon defence |
| BJJ | Ground control & submissions, one-on-one | Going to the ground is risky on the street / vs multiples |
| Muay Thai | Powerful strikes — elbows, knees, kicks, clinch | No ground game or weapon work |
| MMA | All-round, heavily pressure-tested | Sport ruleset; demanding; no weapon defence |
| Karate / TKD | Discipline, structure, great for kids | Traditional styles can be light on realistic pressure |
Krav Maga's whole design goal is self-defence, not points. That gives it three clear advantages: it's fast to learn because it favours simple, instinctive movements; it explicitly trains the messy stuff sport styles leave out — weapons, surprise attacks, multiple opponents, getting back to your feet; and it assumes you might be smaller or weaker, so it leans on leverage and targeting rather than athleticism. If your priority is "I want to be safer, quickly," it's hard to beat.
Combat sports have one big thing going for them: you spar. Boxing and Muay Thai build real punching power and the calm that comes from being hit and carrying on. BJJ gives you genuine control if a fight ends up on the ground, against a fully resisting opponent. MMA blends all of it. That constant live pressure is invaluable, and it's the one area where a well-run sport gym can outpace a weaker Krav Maga class.
For children, traditional arts like karate and taekwondo are excellent for discipline and structure — though so is a good kids' Krav Maga programme built around awareness and confidence.
If self-defence and confidence are your main goals, start with Krav Maga — and choose a school that pressure-tests its material. If you fall in love with training and want more sparring, add boxing or BJJ later; the combination is superb. There's no rule that says you only get to pick one. For a deeper dive on choosing, read the best martial art for self-defence or is Krav Maga effective?
See how it feels for yourself. Two adult trial classes for £19.99, kids' first session free, across four venues in Blackpool and Thornton-Cleveleys.